Get help now

The Concept of Central Argument on the Example of Two Outstanding Novels Essay

Updated August 16, 2022
dovnload

Download Paper

File format: .pdf, .doc, available for editing

The Concept of Central Argument on the Example of Two Outstanding Novels Essay essay

Get help to write your own 100% unique essay

Get custom paper

78 writers are online and ready to chat

This essay has been submitted to us by a student. This is not an example of the work written by our writers.

What is a central argument? How may two novels established in a disassociated setting or whom wish to convey separate ideas, be similar? How do they contrast? A central argument is the backbone of any novel or form of writing. It gives your writing a sense of purpose. And indicates a central message to your audience. “In Cold Blood” a novel published on January 1966 by American novelist and screenwriter Truman Capote, will be examined alongside Wes Moore’s New York’s Bestseller and “Goodreads” nominated Best Memoir, “The Other Wes Moore” (2010). The styles of writing, techniques, and central argument utilized by each author in these works of non-fiction will be evaluated further throughout this composition.

The notion of striving for dreams, and in particular “The American Dream”: is the central idea to “In Cold Blood”. In which the murders of the Clutter’s appear to be the outcome of the murderer’s Dick Hickock and Perry Smith’s incapacity to attain this susceptible concept of the American Dream. This is allowedly comparable to the final interlude of the “The Other Wes Moore”, when Moore asks Wes if he contemplates whether people are deemed to be the outcome of their environments. Wes confesses to this thought in certainty, and further implies that he seems people’s future to be purposive by the expectations of other people; So; “if they are expected to succeed, they will succeed, and if they are expected to fail, they’ll fail.” At last, the “American Dream” only reassembles a fabricated conjecture of social order in its self. Therefore, we could detect a similitude between the protagonists: The “Other Wes” and Perry or Dick in both novels analyzed.

The central image of “The Other Wes Moore” contains itself within the common question of how it remains possible for two men -both born under similar circumstances, and who’ve came so close to even particularly inherit the same name- be diverted onto leading lives that so agitatedly conflict one another. The main characters in “The Other Wes Moore” were raised under reduced circumstances which vividly depicts the habitual misery of violence, vices, and loss. Though the “Other Wes Moore” takes place in an urbanized area in the 1990’s, and contrasts from the setting of “In Cold blood” which is set in 1959, in the small agricultural community of Holcomb, Kansas. The brought up of Perry Smith (specifically) falls in line perfectly, with the synonymous afterthought the “Other Wes” ponders of himself. That given to a previous traumatic past, they’ve been left wounded to an extent to which they’ve downrightly have become capable of evil. Yet, the ideal of Nature vs. Nurture (another central argument of “In Cold Blood”, and the opinion of the “Other Wes”) is challenged due to the fact that in Dick’s “normal” upbringing, there deems not to be any true or natural cause for this criminal behavior.

In reading both novels, I’ve rounded set differences in the styles, and common techniques utilized by the writers. In “The Other Wes Moore” the most recurring writing style used was narrative. Yet, even though the author wrote this novel in first person, there is a constructed juxtaposition that is visible between him and the (other) Wes. This allowed the reviewer an insight of how analogous both persons are, but how their distinct circumstances and decisions to settle led them under divergent tracks. “In Cold Blood” the author also tells his story as a narrative, but with the use of verisimilitude- The appearance of being “true” or real. Capote claimed that the book was downrightly, a real exposition of the Clutter family murders. Therefore, he remained aware that his story must have the authenticity and a journalistic sense – in which utilizing verisimilitude, would uphold his criterion. In addition, the substantial accounts (quotes) from civilians, families, analysts, and the murderers grants the novel a subsidiary perception of non-fiction. The novel is written in a fact-based and unbiased manner, which allows reciprocal astonishment or shock to the reader. For example, the given detail of the way in which this family was slaughtered by its killers: Perry Smith, and Dick Hickock.

“I didn’t want to harm the man. I thought he was a very nice gentleman. Soft-spoken. I thought so right up to the moment I cut his throat.”-Perry, page 244.

On the first-hand, through this quote is a resemblance of irony, a literal device that expresses one’s meaning by using language that normally signifies the opposite. But in fact, in this quote the intention of these murders symbolize to have hold no motive, but instead an indirect execution of frustration and resentment toward the “American dream”- which was considered to have been actualized by the Clutter’s.

A final, yet remarkably potent strategy used throughout the novel, was Capote’s detachment from the story. Altogether, the author remains unaddressed throughout the entirety of the novel. With neither his judgement or opinion included. The authors ostensible neutrality from his publishing, allows him the continuous report and detailing of commonly disturbing character exchanges, or accounts with no employ of scrutiny, or narrator interpretation.

Throughout this disquisition we’ve examined the literary techniques, style, and central arguments of novels “In Cold Blood” and “The Other Wes Moore: One Name, Two Fates”. Both non-fiction narratives shared common likeness and differentiation in composition. In conclusion both novels arguably question mankind’s theory in recognition of what is considered honorary or reprehensible. The protagonists from both novels come to interrogate the reason to their behavior and explore the notion of ‘civilized behavior’ in the societies where they exist, with the use of techniques such as juxtaposition, irony and verisimilitude.

The Concept of Central Argument on the Example of Two Outstanding Novels Essay essay

Remember. This is just a sample

You can get your custom paper from our expert writers

Get custom paper

The Concept of Central Argument on the Example of Two Outstanding Novels Essay. (2022, Aug 16). Retrieved from https://sunnypapers.com/the-concept-of-central-argument-on-the-example-of-two-outstanding-novels-essay/